Idaho Attorney General 2026: Labrador vs. Hickman

Bottom line – The choice is between a proven Republican incumbent with a measurable record and a capable lawyer whose public life has run through progressive causes.

Raúl Labrador (R) has recovered roughly $165–190 million for Idaho since 2023, more than quadrupled arrests for internet crimes against children, cleared a 1,400-tip backlog, and defended Idaho’s laws on women’s sports, school choice and the unborn in court, winning at the U.S. and Idaho Supreme Courts.

Using our affiliate link helps support this site!

Lori Hickman (D) is an experienced business and intellectual-property lawyer with no prosecutorial or government-executive experience. For about five years she chaired Mormon Women for Ethical Government, a group that sued to overturn Idaho’s school-choice tax credit, a law Labrador’s office successfully defended. Every political donation on record goes to Democrats, including $5,000 to the Idaho Democratic Party in 2026.

Hickman’s main argument is ethics and professionalism, backed by endorsements from former Republican attorneys general Lawrence Wasden and Jim Jones.

Support Gem State Patriot

Labrador’s strongest argument is results from his four years as Idaho’s AG. He also has a proven record as a conservative Congressman and Legislator.

Side by side

	Raúl Labrador (R, incumbent)	Lori Hickman (D, challenger)
Current role	Idaho Attorney General since January 2023; former U.S. congressman	Attorney at McFarland Ritter PLLC, Boise, since 2014
Prosecution / law enforcement experience	Runs the office’s prosecutors, ICAC task force and Medicaid Fraud Control Unit	None found; civil, business and IP practice; pro bono counsel in child-protection cases
Money recovered for Idaho	$161M in first 18 months; about $165–190M total including Purdue opioid share (up to $24M)	Not applicable
Child-exploitation arrests (ICAC)	143 in 2025, vs. 34 in 2022 under the previous AG	Not applicable
School choice (HB 93 tax credit)	Defended it; Idaho Supreme Court upheld it 5–0 in Feb. 2026; challengers paid Idaho $70,000 in fees	Chaired the board of a group that sued to strike it down
Women’s sports and child-protection laws	Defended at U.S. Supreme Court and 9th Circuit	Says she would end “culture war” litigation
Lawsuits against the Biden administration	Won injunctions or rulings on parole, Obamacare for illegal immigrants, minimum wage, Corporate Transparency Act	Not applicable
Immigration enforcement	Won a ruling against the Biden administration’s immigrant parole program	Would let local law enforcement decide whether to participate
Political giving	Not researched for this guide	All recorded donations to Democrats, incl. $5,000 to the Idaho Democratic Party (2026)
Fundraising (2026)	$552,742 by May	$173,433 itemized through Sept. 29; top donor A.J. Balukoff ($10,000)
Notable endorsements	Not researched for this guide	Former GOP AGs Lawrence Wasden and Jim Jones
Bar discipline	None found	None found
Primary result (May 2026)	Unopposed	Unopposed, 43,348 votes
Polling	49%	31% (20% undecided)

Labrador’s record

Labrador has brought in about five times his office’s $33.6 million annual budget in his first 18 months alone and has made child exploitation a top enforcement priority.

Money recovered for Idaho

Case	Idaho’s share
Tobacco company payment disputes	$74 million
Opioid makers, distributors and pharmacies (Teva, Allergan, CVS, Walgreens and others)	$78 million
Johnson & Johnson talc baby powder (43 states, $700M total)	$5.7 million
Purdue Pharma and the Sacklers ($7.4B total)	Up to $24 million over 15 years
Medicaid fraud, federal FY2025	$900,756, the most outside multistate cases in a decade
Consumer mediation, 2025 through June 2026	About $2.06 million, more than all years since 2017 combined
HB 93 school-choice lawsuit fee award	$70,000 paid by the challengers

Most of the large recoveries are multistate settlements, several begun under his predecessor and finished by Labrador’s office. The Medicaid, consumer and HB 93 recoveries came from his office’s own work.

Protecting children

Internet Crimes Against Children arrests rose to 143 in 2025, from 90 in 2024, 62 in 2023 and 34 in 2022.
A backlog of more than 1,400 unworked child-exploitation tips was cleared; new tips are now reviewed within 24 hours, down from more than 17 days.
Operation Unhinged (April 2025) made 12 arrests and served 17 search warrants with the FBI, Homeland Security and 20-plus local agencies.
The office added Badger, a K-9 trained to find hidden phones and hard drives, used on more than 30 warrants.
His Special Prosecutions Unit filed 101 cases in 2025, up from 36 in 2023.
He championed HB 465 (2024), making AI-generated child sexual abuse images a crime, one of the first such laws in the nation.

Defending Idaho law

Women’s sports law: argued at the U.S. Supreme Court, January 2026.
Vulnerable Child Protection Act: allowed to take effect after a 2024 U.S. Supreme Court ruling.
Sex-separated facilities law: upheld unanimously by the 9th Circuit.
School-choice tax credit: upheld 5–0 by the Idaho Supreme Court.
Federal overreach: wins against Biden-era rules on immigrant parole, Obamacare for illegal immigrants, the contractor minimum wage and the Corporate Transparency Act.

One caution: his office reported 2024 ICAC arrests as 55 in an August 2025 letter and 90 in December, likely a change in counting method. Either figure is a record.

Hickman’s record

Hickman’s legal career is solid but entirely in private civil practice, and her most visible public role was leading a group that sued the state over school choice.

Background

Raised in the Treasure Valley; Borah High School; BYU (business, magna cum laude, 1988); BYU law (cum laude, 1991). Married to Craig, three children; about 30 years in Boise.
Career: Latham & Watkins in New York; Holme Roberts & Owen in Salt Lake City; associate general counsel at Micron (1996–2002); ten years at home raising children (2002–2012); federal court law clerk in Idaho (2012); McFarland Ritter since 2014.
No prosecutorial, law-enforcement or government-management experience found.

Mormon Women for Ethical Government (MWEG)

She chaired the group’s national board for about five years, stepping down shortly before her campaign.
The group calls itself nonpartisan. Critics, including former members and the watchdog InfluenceWatch, describe it as left-of-center: it called for President Trump’s second impeachment, aligned with Black Lives Matter in 2020, opposed Jim Jordan for House speaker, and is funded in part by the Gates, Hewlett and Packard foundations.
In September 2025 MWEG joined the Idaho Education Association and others in suing to overturn Idaho’s Parental Choice Tax Credit (HB 93). Labrador’s office defended the law, the Idaho Supreme Court upheld it 5–0, and the challengers paid Idaho $70,000 in fees. The suit appears to have been filed while she chaired the board; her personal role in the decision is not documented.
The Idaho chapter, led by former Democratic superintendent candidate Cindy Wilson, also testified in 2022 against a bill adding reporting requirements for refugee-assistance groups.

Money and politics

Her campaign reported $173,433 in itemized contributions through Sept. 29, 2026, mostly small Idaho donors (median gift $50); $9,597 came from out of state.
Top donors: A.J. Balukoff, the 2014 Democratic nominee for governor ($10,000), and a James Jones ($5,000), likely the former AG who endorsed her.
Her own giving since 2024 has gone only to Democrats: Reps. Ilana Rubel and Sonia Galaviz, Sen. Janie Ward-Engelking, Ada County Democrats, and $5,000 to the Idaho Democratic Party in June 2026.

Her case to voters

She runs on ethics and “professionalism over politics,” promising to stop what she calls culture-war lawsuits. No bar discipline was found.

Questions to ask

For Hickman

Did you vote, as MWEG board chair, to join the lawsuit against Idaho’s school-choice tax credit? As AG, would you defend that law?
Which of Labrador’s lawsuits against the federal government would you have dropped?
You have never prosecuted a case. How will you run an office of prosecutors and the ICAC task force?
Would you keep the ICAC unit’s current arrest pace and 24-hour tip response?
Have you ever been registered as, or given to, a Republican?

For Labrador

How much of the $161 million came from cases your office started, versus multistate settlements begun before you?
Why did your office’s count of 2024 ICAC arrests change from 55 to 90?
How much has Idaho spent on outside counsel and losing attorney fees in policy lawsuits since 2023?

Sources

Most Labrador figures come from his own office and have not been independently audited. Hickman’s donor figures were pulled directly from Idaho’s Sunshine campaign-finance database. Not checked: federal (FEC) donations for either candidate, Hickman’s current bar standing, and state court records.